31
A few Words about Originality… by David Niall Wilson
Category: writingQuick note - there is no regular “columnist” for the 31st of a month, and since no one was “on deck” for today, I’m posting a day early to cover today and the 1st, my normal day.
HAPPY HALLOWEEN!
I’d like to write something this time out about trends, trend-setting, and originality. This is an issue that rears its ugly head in so many ways that when we get swept up in the currents it creates, we are often unaware that anything has happened. It’s important at such times to keep one’s head above water, so to speak, and the world in perspective.
It has been said that there is nothing new. In many ways, this is true. Originality is rare, and quite often, it isn’t popular. If you do something new, the first thing that is going to happen is that those people doing the old thing will rebel. Others will scoff or look for hidden tricks and motivators. Bandwagons usually travel their first few miles quite empty of passengers, or freight.
Editors and publishers will tell you they are always on the lookout for the next Steinbeck, or Hemingway, or Stephen King, or Toni Morrison. On some level, they probably believe this is a good thing. The problem is that they are literally doing exactly what they say they are. They aren’t looking for something sparkling new and original, they are looking for the next marketable version of something that has already run the gauntlet and proven itself. If they can’t put “The next so-and-so” or “Lovers of whatshisname will love this as well” on the cover, they are stymied. You can push a fad or a trend as far as you like, but the bottom line is that it ceased to be original the moment the second person started doing it. This is the business of writing, as opposed to the art. This is commercial art as opposed to fine art. It is not a bad thing, but it is also not the same thing.
When you pitch to TV or the movies what they want to hear first is your logline. Some of the most popular loglines are merely blends of known products. “Think ‘The Crow’ meets ‘Saturday Night Live’,” is the kind of thing you’ll hear, or “The Temple of Doom with Charlie’s Angels instead of Harrison Ford.” This mentality is ruled by the marketplace, and buzz words are marketable. Fads are marketable. Originality? A much tougher nut to crack, and once you get past the shell you still have to convince the cashew people it’s okay to try something else.
Even if you are original, and you manage to slide your new “thing” past the first couple of road-blocks, don’t be surprised if it ends up presented to the world in a wrapper that resembles that of the previous fad. It’s like giving your pet a pill wrapped in hamburger or cheese. Marketing folks believe if they take a novel and make it look and sound like something familiar, the reader will be sucked in. They have no faith in the new “thing” to take off on its own, but figure if they can sell a good first round of copies on the hype leftover from the OLD thing, then they’ll make their money. Anything beyond that is gravy – despite the fact they may have cut the legs out from under the new thing with their approach. It’s a fad-eat-fad world out there. Be trendy and willing to be bendy, as they say.
This isn’t a thing that is likely to be fixed, or to go away. I’m not suggesting that we fight to change the world, just that we be aware of what we are doing and aware of the place of what we are doing in the greater scheme of things. Religions are a good example of the group mentality of the human race. At the core of most religious belief there are those who study, truly believe in a thing, and present it to the world. The majority of the world will choose among those things presented, latch onto one, and claim it for his/her own without much thought about why they believe it, without much understanding of the concepts behind it, and without even considering putting all the pieces of the world as they know it together into their own spiritual consciousness. This, of course, allows for exploitation. Organized religion is the spiritual marketplace of the world, and it runs on the same principles as publishing and movie making. Give the people something familiar, squash originality if possible and incorporate it as your own if it won’t be squashed. Above all, and push the product.
So, what is the point? It is simply this; if you set out to write a book, or a story, be aware of what you are trying to accomplish. If you are a lover of brain-eating zombies, and are setting out to write a brain-eating zombie epic, more power to you, and to your project. Make it the best brain-eating zombie story it can be, but don’t forget that it is your version of what has come before. If you do as I’ve done in the past with some success, and present a new version of an old story, never lose sight of the fact it’s an old story and that you are adding to it, not creating a new “thing”.
If you want to do something new, realize the fight that you have ahead of you, and grit your teeth for the onslaught. Realize that even when you believe you are doing something new, you may be influenced in ways you aren’t aware of on the surface. Others will see it even if you don’t; don’t be surprised when they point it out. Probably ninety-nine percent of all things touted as new and original are based on some earlier fad or trend in some way if you chase them to their core, and this isn’t necessarily a bad thing – it’s the way human mind appears to operate. Still, originality of concept can happen. If it does, and it becomes popular, it will become a fad, or a trend. It will become marketable, and runners will be sent to the far corners to find the next person who can do it well enough, and the next, until it’s hard to tell where and when it all started.
You will know, of course, and you can smile when you see your name on the cover of a new book…not as the author, but because the author of that book is the next you. I hope the next me has more hair…
DNW













