by John B. Rosenman
A long time ago, there was this gorilla I knew. I was out of work, and the gorilla was similarly unemployed. At least he appeared to be, for every time I went to the Minneapolis zoo, all 800 pounds of him would be waiting for me at the cage bars like he didn’t have anything else to do. I swear the guy hadn’t moved an inch, and his expression was always direct and unchanging. “You poor jerk,” his brown marble stare seemed to say. “You still haven’t got a job, do you?”
I used to stare into those brown orbs, trying to make Mr. G look away. Never succeeded or even came close. For hours I tried to stare him down, wondering all the time, “What the hell’s going through your head? What are you thinking? What do you think of me? What are you trying to do?” I guess I was a little like Captain Ahab who obsessed about that great white whale, wondering what made it tick and if it had chomped off his leg because it was pissed off or just because it was doing its stupid, meaningless whale thing. Anyway, I’d stare and stare and after a while, I’d try to become that fucking gorilla. I WILL BE YOU! I thought. I WILL GET INTO YOUR FURRY HEAD AND BECOME YOU. I CAN MAKE THE IMAGINATIVE LEAP, I CAN!
Well, I never succeeded. Just as well of course, since I don’t know what I would have done with his 500 pound female companion. But my experience did have one tangible result. I wrote a poem:
GORILLA
Wrapped in a bulging sack of fur
The gorilla stares
Down my winding mind,
Unblinking.
He is grotesque.
In primal maze a memory stirs.
I lift a musty arm
To paw a marble eye.
Words are vines untangling.
The gorilla climbs
Through my combed hair,
Gathers a jungle around my mouth
to swarm in sun,
Suddenly
I am hunger
leaping at hairless flesh
to tear blood wisdom
from its tongue.
Okay, it ain’t great, but my point here has to do with the way I get my ideas. They come straight from Schenectedy. No, forget that. Bad old joke. What I should have said is that most of my ideas tend to just jump out at me, often completely unpremeditated. That’s the way I wrote “Gorilla.” I just sat down and . . . scribbled, let the pen have its way.
George Guthridge has a much more systematic method for generating stories, a brilliant nonfiction idea machine that has resulted in professional sales for both himself and his students. His articles (actually a series) are posted on this site, and I encourage everyone to check them out. I don’t have anything quite as good or elaborate, but I thought it might be interesting to share my “method,” to the extent that I have one. Please note that not all my stories have their genesis in such a spontaneous, unplanned, non-cerebral way, but most of them do.
One place I like to hang out is Barnes & Noble. There’s a huge one in Chesapeake, VA which I haunt. What I do is walk around, sometimes with a cup of java in my hand, and let my eyes roam. Often titles will ignite something inside me. Once I saw a book whose title was The Calm Technique. Bam! At once a similar but significantly different title leapt into my mind: The Death Technique. It’s about a man who’s able to will or cause his own decomposition and liquefaction – in other words, appear to die and rot. Lord knows, how one glance at that title inspired such a ghoulish tale. No wait, I think I do know. My horrific instincts simply “decided” to create the ghoulish opposite of a “Calm” technique. Look for it in HWA’s Dark Arts anthology.
I guess my main point here is that sometimes you should get in touch with your own inner gorilla and learn to love him. Open yourself up to inspiration and take chances. Trust your subconscious and avoid analysis and excessive thinking. Go with the flow and toss your safety net. Forget about outlines, scripts and character thumbnail sketches. Make it up as you go along.
Sometimes I haven’t had to make much up at all. Recently I opened a book of stories – at Barnes & Noble of course – and a story just leapt into my head. It was more or less fully conceived, though I didn’t read even one word in the book. Turned out to be one of my better stories too.
Some stories I’ve written have had bizarre origins.
One day a sentence flashed across my mind: “I’m sitting in hell listening to Barry Manilow records when the call came.” I had no idea in hell what it meant, but I used the sentence to begin a pretty good SF novelette.
Similar to that, I made up a word, “Dreamfarer,” which I used as the title and inspiration for a whole novel. Okay, the novel sucked, but the title itself
was great.
One of my students became a little obsessive. She started to stalk me a bit.
Did I mention she didn’t have good eyesight? One night she pulled up outside my house in her trademark chartreuse van. My wife was upset but I wasn’t. Hell, I had a great story idea about a guy who’s terrorized by a girl who drives a chartreuse van, and I went right upstairs and wrote it.
Back in ’87, I published an article on this subject. I called it “Stories Without Ideas,” and I thought I’d close with some excerpts.
. . . Readers might be interested in a phenomenon that’s happened to me more and more in the past few years: Stories come to me WITHOUT ideas.
What’s my point? Simply that for some writers, beginning stories without (or almost without) ideas may be a viable and productive approach, and it may be folly to wait until something more solid develops. True, you must have SOMETHING, but it may only need to be an interesting phrase or word, a potential title, or a vague question or sentiment. Here are some other examples from my own experience.
I remember reading once, somewhere, that the most frightening and horrifying thing of all is when a rose sings. The quote rattled around in my mental teapot for years till I finally wrote “When A Rose Sings,” which appeared in 2AM Magazine. When I started writing, all I had was the dimly remembered quote, but it metamorphosed into a story about a divinely lovely rose perverted by hard rock music into a flower that mesmerizes its victims by singing. Happens all the time, right?
Recently, another potential title whomped me: “Two Moons East of Tomorrow.” No way I was gonna let that stunner pass. After a false start, the title’s seed burgeoned into a tale about an alien being who can recapture the past by using people who lived it.
One last example: a year ago, I took my seven-year-old son David out on Halloween, and as he ran up a curved path to a house, he disappeared briefly behind a trellis. A question briefly nudged me in a way that scribblers as opposed to normal people train themselves not to ignore: What if that did happen, and the father couldn’t find his son? The result is “Daniel, My Son” [which remains one of my favorites].
“Where do you get your ideas?” I believe the answer to this question is endless because the creative process may be a mystery to the writer itself, submerged in a subconscious realm he can’t fathom. But to me, that’s part of the fun, the fascination, and the glory, for to bring something out of nothing is as godlike as any of us mortals are likely to get. So, fellow writers – pay heed to those unorthodox, sometimes barely perceptible nudges and flashes. It just may be a story knocking!

7 Comments, Comment or Ping
Frank Wydra
Hey John, listening to Barry Manilow records in hell is a horror story.
But your right, if you let them in, the ideas come, not always in a form that you welcome, not always at a place or time that’s convenient, but they push themselves in on you like a glutton at a food fest. You can either let him at the food or become the meat.
But, I’m not sure I understand the stories without ideas part. Seems to me, what you were describing were catalysts for stories, which, whether they be words or images, were in themselves ideas. I’m going to need some help on that one.
But, no matter where it came from, good piece, and true.
Frank
Nov 14th, 2006
Teresa
I’m not sure I understand the stories without ideas part. -frank
Oddly enough I think I do ‘get’ what John means. And I think too that you are right when you say that phrases, thoughts, images etc. are ideas.
I think it has to do with the sense of knowing that ‘you know’ there is a story in that ‘flash’ before you know what that story may be. It’s like digging a needle out of a bale of hay; you just have to keep going because you have absolute trust that the needle is there because your best friend said it was, or like the sculpter that stares at a chunk of rock until the figure it is meant to be carved into ‘appears’ for him and he can start to carve.
I think the trick -no!- the talent, is to be able to grab those flashes and trust that where ever they are in your mind they can be revealed if you trust yourself to dig long and hard enough.
I get the ’storys without ideas’ bit; the digging them out of my brain part is proving to be a difficult challenge so far. Sometines it really does feel as though I’m trying to hard.
Thanks John, for the encouraging words. I mustn’t be too crazy if someone else has put words to a process in my own brain I so poorly understand.
Nov 15th, 2006
David Niall Wilson
I actually think the poem is extraordinary, but what do I know? I’m one of those few folks left who spend a long time staring at paintings, or actually READ poetry…
I love this question, because of all the old staples, it is the most diverse in it’s answers….
Nov 15th, 2006
Janet Berliner
I’m with you, John. I see something or read something. It gripts my gut and won’t let go until I make it part of a story or a novel.
Like David, I think the poem is terrific.
Janet
Nov 15th, 2006
John B. Rosenman
Thanks for your comments, folks. Teresa is right: it is sometimes like a flash and digging a needle out of a pile of hay. Other times it’s easy, almost effortless. As I get older though, it gets harder and harder and requires work.
Frank, I believe I hedged my bets a bit and said something like “Almost Without” ideas. Anyway, when I saw the title, “The Calm Technique,” I don’t think the title even registered as an idea or concept. The other title flashed into my mind almost at once. So it was a catalyst, but perhaps not even an idea. Or if it was an idea, it was a very, very rudimentary one. Does that make sense? My major point is that sometimes the inspiration or origin of a story is very flimsy, just a feeling or spontaneous notion.
Now, to take another example I mentioned: Several months ago I picked up a book of stories and the pages opened randomly to one of them. Just the arrangement of words or print on the page caused a story idea to leap into my mind. Aha, a story about an ad man who creates in his mind a bigger, older, far more capable brother that becomes real. In this case, I had essentially the whole story. I “just” had to write it. Yet there was no “idea” that birthed it.
I guess another way to put it is that sometimes a story can be generated by a frail hint. The story component may be there, but it’s -very- small.
Glad you liked the poem, Dave and Janet. Thanks!
Nov 15th, 2006
Mark Rainey
Prof — You are a strange man.
Gorillas and Barry Manilow. I know -I’m- afraid now.
Your processes work a little too eerily like mine, though. It’s an odd place, these minds of ours, though I’d never change a thing.
By the way — what’s with that guy in that INSIDIOUS REFLECTIONS story that has such a familiar name? A bad guy again… Oy!
–M
Nov 16th, 2006
John B. Rosenman
Mark — yep, I’m strange all right. I scare myself sometimes.
As to the origin of this story, it fits in perfectly with my essay. One day Dave Wilson mentioned your name, and a psychotic serial killer named Rainey just leaped into my mind. Don’t ask me why.
Nov 16th, 2006
Reply to “Gorilla, My Love”